I Love N.Y Pizza

Takisha Richardson 2 months ago

The cauliflower crust here is the best I have had in Gainesville FL. The pizza was full of flavor. The garlic cheese bread was delicious 😋

Bob Ablah 4 months ago

So happy to find New York style pizza in Gainesville. And this one is really pretty good. Lots of veggie options, including the hard-to-find eggplant as a topping. The create-your-own calzones are fantastic! We also like their tiramisu for dessert. Worth the drive to Haile area, but they also deliver. Highly recommend.

Jamahl Rawls 9 months ago

I love this place, but, more importantly, my girlfriend loves this place. Today was my girlfriend’s birthday, and management accommodated our party of 18 (11 adults, 7 children) with little more than a 30-minute heads up. The food was great as always (we got pizzas, wings, fries, and desserts), but it was the service that really impressed me. Our group took up the space between the kitchen door and the restroom, but staff worked around us seamlessly. They tended to us throughout the party. They even insisted on helping us rearrange tables and chairs during setup so that we could all be seated together. I couldn’t have asked for more. In the words of my gf, “Best birthday ever!” 👁️ ❤️🗽🍕

Love Kumar a year ago

We've been to I Love N.Y Pizza many times and usually love their food, especially the paneer pizza. However, our last visit was a bit disappointing. The pizza we received was clearly overcooked, but when we brought it up, the staff insisted it wasn't burned. That was frustrating, but aside from that, the experience was still decent. The atmosphere and other menu items were as good as always. Hoping for better consistency next time!

Melissa Narum 3 years ago

We ordered delivery a few weeks ago at work. We ordered over the phone and the service was great. The pizza was a huge hit and disappeared quickly. Highly recommend the pepperoni rolls and the Roma pizza!! We will definitely order from here again